Deathly Hallows *Spoliers*

[Narcissa Malfoy]

Okay so what where everyones veiws on the story?


I cant belive she had Snape killed! It like broke my heart lol but i cant wait to see it in the movie!

[Ron Weasley]

I thought it was a really good ending to the series. Although there is talk that she may be writing a 8th. Truthfully i don't think she will be. Anyway.

It was a wonderful book. I loved the way Hermione and Ron got together. And when Hermione was punching him i was like "You go girl!". I also loved Mrs. Weasley in the end. I never would have thought she would say something like that. But the things parents will do for they're children. I absolutely loved her.

But i also thought she should had killed one of the Trio. Maybe not Harry, but at least Ron or Hermione. It would have been sad, but it would have also been good at the same time. (That doesn't even make sense but whatever. XP)

[Narcissa Malfoy]

No i thought she should have killed one of the trio..and in a way she killed Harry...im quite surprised she killed tonks and lupin though!

[Ron Weasley]

Oh i know! That was sad. But i liked how Percy finally came back. After those few years. I never liked Percy, but he finally realized that family has to stick together.

[Narcissa Malfoy]

I still dnt really like percy, i thought it was sweet that harry named one of his children Albus Severus awwwwwww bless.

But it annoys me though cause my friend who hated snape now loves him, but im glad he was good cause im like ha ha ha to my mates now who didnt believe me :0

Its also groove that Narcissa was in it more!

[Ron Weasley]

Haha. I always suspected that Snape wasn't the bad one. That he was really on our side. But every time Rowling supported my ideas, she turned around and made him seem bad again. lol.

[Narcissa Malfoy]

lol i reckon she wasnt sure herself i bet she had two versions.

[Severus Snape]

I knew snape wasn't bad lol, and i had a feeling he had been in love with Lily, however i didn't think that the doe was HIS patronus now that suprised me. I felt sorry for him though. i mean he didn't really have to die. I mean i know why he did, but it didnt seem fair cuz i mean he wasn't the true owner of the Elder Wand then agian Voldemort didn't know that, but still

[Amiel Phelps]

Well I thought I would go on some of the predictions I made and see what was right rather than posting just an opinion on the story cause, in my opinion, it
a) had a fanfiction ending
b) was written badly compared to her other stories
c) completely threw everything out the window.


Hermione and Ron not a couple
I thought that the two of them being a couple was far too obvious and no-one can deny that it was obvious but I honestly did not think that they would get together. In a way I was right cause they are not technically together til the end but they end up together eventually so this prediction was proved F A L S E

R.A.B is Regulas Black
Well I think this was a widely supported theory since the sixth book came out and I am glad to say that it was T R U E

All the marauders will be dead by the end of the book and they will die in reverse order
Well all the marauders were dead and guess what, they died in reverse order. If you dont understand look at their names on the Marauders Map: Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, Prongs. James Potter died first, Sirius died second Peter third and finally Remus died. The marauders died in reverse order. T R U E

Pettigrew's life debt will play a crucial role
This could be classified as either true or false. When Harry otld Pettigrew that he, harry, had saved his life Pettigrew showed remorse and was, therefore, killed by the silver hand. T R U E

All Marauders will be murdered
James died at the hand of Voldemort. Sirius died at the hand of Bellatrix, Peter died at the hand of the hand he was given by Voldemort. Remus died at the hand of a death eater T R U E

Harry and Luna's link (i.e. both seeing thestrals, both hearing voices behind the veil) will play a crucial role
I'm sad to say that this is F A L S E there was nothing more mentioned about the fact that Harry and Luna share these connections.

There is something more to Sirius' death
I'm sad to say that this is F A L S E there was nothing more mentioned about Sirius' death other than the fact he was gone.

There is something more to Dumbledore's death, he planned his death
This was T R U E until now many thought that Snape killed Dumbledore out of pure hatred but I never believed it for a second. Dumbledore pleading with Snape was something more for someone who embraced the possibility of death.

The horcruxes: the Diary, the Ring, the Locket, the Cup, the Snake, something of Ravenclaw's
T R U E this earns a big tick from me. These were the horcruxes that were WILLINGLY created. We could, however, debate that these were all of the horcruxes given that Harry was a horcrux as well, though he was an unwilling one.

Hermione, Ron, Ginny, Luna and Neville
Neville, Ron, Hermione, Ginny and Luna are the only DA members who have supported Harry in the 5th and 6th books when fighting and I think that they will play a role in the final battle particularly Neville because we notice that he improves throughout the whole series and once he faces Bellatrix Lestrange he is more determined than ever to fight and because she had something to do with his parents insanity (tortured them with the cruciatus curse) i think that he will be the one to fight beside Harry and the one who plays the most crucial role.
Well we can see that this one is T R U E. Neville, besides Ron and Hermione, plays the most crucial role he does, like I predicted, assist in getting rid of the horcruxes (killing the snake). Neville is also a lot more confident as a wizard in the seventh book and, rather than being very shy and such he took Harry's place in the classes.

As for the Order: they will continue and definately fight.
T R U E nothing more needs to be said.

We learn something significant about Petunia
T R U E, we learn that she originally wanted to go to Hogwarts. Not to mention we learn that when she says (refering to dementors) 'I heard that awful boy telling her about them' she is not refering to James (like many people, including myself, thought) but is actually refering to Severus Snape.

Dobby will die for Harry: saving Harry
T R U E, sadly. Dobby died while rescuing Harry from the Malfoy Manor.

i also think that the main characters from Beauxbatons and Durmstrang will come into the book
T R U E, Fleur gets married to Bill and Krum comes to the wedding and gives information to Harry about Gregorovich

Kreacher helped Regulas get the locket
T R U E, Kreacher is the second 'person' that goes across the lake when Regulas goes across. Kreacher has to obey orders no matter what and that is how he helped Regulas.

Kreacher is an unknown quantity with me at the moment. I know he is insane but I think there is something else about him that we are not understanding
T R U E, Kreacher is nice to those who are nice to him. He was told to keep quiet by Regulas and is upset for not fullfilling his orders.

finally I dont think that snape is evil. I refuse to believe it and I dont think that Narcissa Malfoy is either, I think she is doing things ONLY because of Draco and Lucius
T R U E, I have already proven that Snape was not evil, Dumbledore planned the death, he was taking dumbledore's orders even after death. Narcissa Malfoy is not either and neither is Lucius, they both worry more about Draco rather than the dark lord winning. For Example: Narcissa lies to Voldemort about Harry being dead.

[Narcissa Malfoy]

finally I dont think that snape is evil. I refuse to believe it and I dont think that Narcissa Malfoy is either, I think she is doing things ONLY because of Draco and Lucius
T R U E, I have already proven that Snape was not evil, Dumbledore planned the death, he was taking dumbledore's orders even after death. Narcissa Malfoy is not either and neither is Lucius, they both worry more about Draco rather than the dark lord winning. For Example: Narcissa lies to Voldemort about Harry being dead.

I thought this as well I thought that Lucius followed the Dark Lord for money and power but would always put his family first, and Narcissa went along with it because he was her husband and she had to surpport him.


I still cant get over the fact she killed Snape, I thought if he died then he would die saving Harrys life, i kinda thought she didnt give snape enough credit in his death.

I thought she WOULD kill one of the trio and was quite disapointed when she didnt.

[Dane Carnahan]

Okay, I have a few things to say about it as well.

Fred's death.
Good gosh, I new is was gonna happen thanks to spoilers, but Fred+wall? Come on now, he was one of my most favorite characters! She could've at least given him a better death! Seriously. I was like, "DDDD:!" I don't think he died. It was a joke between him and George. For reals.

Moody's Death.
Thankfully this one hadn't been spoiled, but it was like WHAM. I'll admit, I cried. Really.

Lupin and Tonks.
When I read that they go married I was like "YAYZ!" Even baby Teddy, aww. He inherited his mother's abilities, I thought it was adorable. I didn't expect them to die, though. Lupin was also one of my favorite characters, and I can safely say that I'll be crying a lot during the Deathly Hallows movie.

Snape and Lily.
I swear, that was the most adorable thing ever. "We'll always be friends, right?" and she left him for James? Bah! I think she should've went with Snape, it would've been the cutest thing ever. Honestly. And his patronus looking like hers? If someone's patronus looked like mine, dang. I realize I'm probably not making any sense, but whatever.

Fenrir Greyback!
He's probably my most favorite character. Of all time. I wouldn't mind letting him eat half my arm. ;] Honestly, I was so happy he got a bigger part. They better not cut his scenes out of the movie, and he'd better be running around in the background during the final fight, otherwise WB's gonna have a very disgruntled fan on their hands.

The Epilogue.
That... confused me, to say the least. I had to reread paragraphs like three times before I understood anything. And the names of the children, blegh. I could understand naming his children James and Lily, though. The only thing I really liked about it was Scorpious Malfoy; he had like, one sentence and it was adorable.

[Amiel Phelps]

admin said:

finally I dont think that snape is evil. I refuse to believe it and I dont think that Narcissa Malfoy is either, I think she is doing things ONLY because of Draco and Lucius
T R U E, I have already proven that Snape was not evil, Dumbledore planned the death, he was taking dumbledore's orders even after death. Narcissa Malfoy is not either and neither is Lucius, they both worry more about Draco rather than the dark lord winning. For Example: Narcissa lies to Voldemort about Harry being dead.

I thought this as well I thought that Lucius followed the Dark Lord for money and power but would always put his family first, and Narcissa went along with it because he was her husband and she had to surpport him.


I still cant get over the fact she killed Snape, I thought if he died then he would die saving Harrys life, i kinda thought she didnt give snape enough credit in his death.

I thought she WOULD kill one of the trio and was quite disapointed when she didnt.

I agree with you on all of those. Snape died right before he really had a chance if you think about it.

I was sure Hermione would die, she's too smart and such and I really don't like her as a character.

I WILL NEVER FORGIVE HER FOR KILLING DOBBY even if sI did expect it

but one more point people are over looking. Harry and Voldemort are distantly related. How you ask? Voldemort's grandfather, Marvolo Gaunt, says he is descended from the Peveralls (he's descended from the second brother - he had the ring with the ressurection stone) and Harry is descended from the third brother (the cloak was passed down to Harry starting from Ignotus Peverall)

[Harry Potter]

Snape and Lily.
I swear, that was the most adorable thing ever. "We'll always be friends, right?" and she left him for James? Bah! I think she should've went with Snape, it would've been the cutest thing ever. Honestly. And his patronus looking like hers? If someone's patronus looked like mine, dang. I realize I'm probably not making any sense, but whatever.

Dude, if they went together, thered be no harry potter.

[Ping Yan Lin]

I think It'd be interesting if Harry was a Snape. That'd make things interesting, having both a kind mother but a voldemort supporting father. It could make a good story.

[Narcissa Malfoy]

AWW I wish Snape had got together with someone..it would have been soo cute! bless him.

But JK Never gave him a big enough exit, i was so disapointed *sniffles*